From The Guardian-
There has been a rash of books in recent years by thinkers for whom the human race is getting nicer and nicer. Richard Dawkins, Steven Pinker, Matt Ridley
and Sam Harris are rational humanists who believe in progress, however
many famines and genocides may disfigure the planet. We are en route to a
vastly improved future. Perhaps this return to the values of the
western Enlightenment is not unrelated to the threat of radical Islam.
The philosopher John Gray’s
role has been to act as a Jeremiah among these Pollyannas, insisting
that we are every bit as nasty as we ever were. If there is anything he
detests, it is schemes of visionary transformation. He is a
card-carrying misanthrope for whom human life has no unique importance,
and for whom history has been little more than the sound of hacking and
gouging. One might note that Christianity is as pessimistic as Gray but a
lot more hopeful as well.
The answer to the question of whether history has been improving is
surely a decisive yes and no. For Marx, the modern age was both an
enthralling emancipation and one long nightmare. The wide-eyed optimism of Pinker
or Ridley is just as one-sided as the prophets of doom who refuse to
concede that there is something to be said for such modern inventions as
feminism, spin-dryers and antibiotics. The truth is that everyone
believes in progress, but only a dwindling band of Victorian relics such
as Dawkins believe in Progress. So this book is really hammering at an
open door. How many champions of a vastly improved future are there in a
postmodern culture?
More here-
https://www.theguardian.com/books/2018/apr/11/seven-types-atheism-john-gray-review-atheist-believer-material-world?CMP=share_btn_fb
Opinion – 21 December 2024
1 day ago
No comments:
Post a Comment